How to Manage Payroll for Nonprofits: Tips for Bookkeepers
Payroll is often one of the largest expenses for nonprofits, and managing it correctly is essential to maintaining compliance, keeping staff happy, and ensuring accurate financial reporting. Nonprofit bookkeepers face unique challenges, such as tracking grant-funded positions or managing payroll taxes for employees and contractors. Here’s a guide to managing payroll effectively in the nonprofit sector.
1. Understand the Components of Payroll
Payroll involves more than just cutting checks—bookkeepers must manage multiple components.
Key Components:
Gross Wages: Employee salaries, hourly wages, and bonuses.
Deductions: Taxes, retirement contributions, health insurance premiums, and other withholdings.
Employer Taxes and Benefits: Social Security, Medicare, state unemployment, and other employer-paid benefits.
Reimbursements: Payments for approved expenses, like travel or supplies.
Pro Tip: Maintain detailed records for each employee, including tax forms (W-4, I-9) and benefit selections.
2. Choose the Right Payroll System
The right system can streamline payroll processing and reduce errors.
Options for Nonprofits:
Full-Service Payroll Providers: Gusto, ADP, or Paychex handle tax filings, direct deposit, and compliance.
Integrated Accounting Software: QuickBooks Online and Xero offer payroll modules for seamless tracking.
Grant-Specific Tools: For grant-funded organizations, consider platforms that allow cost allocation by funding source.
Pro Tip: Look for systems that integrate with your accounting software to save time.
3. Track Employee and Contractor Status
Nonprofits often employ a mix of full-time, part-time, and contract workers.
Key Differences:
Employees: Receive wages subject to payroll taxes and benefits.
Contractors: Paid via Form 1099-NEC, without tax withholdings or employer-paid benefits.
Pro Tip: Misclassifying workers can lead to penalties—review IRS guidelines to ensure compliance.
4. Allocate Payroll Costs Properly
Many nonprofits must allocate payroll costs to different programs or funding sources.
How to Allocate Costs:
Track hours by program or grant using timesheets or time-tracking software.
Use a percentage-based allocation for salaried employees who work across multiple areas.
Document the methodology for allocations to support audits and grant reporting.
Pro Tip: Align payroll allocations with your budget to ensure consistency.
5. Stay Compliant with Tax Regulations
Nonprofit payroll taxes can be complex, especially if your organization operates in multiple states.
Key Tax Responsibilities:
Federal Taxes: Withhold and remit Social Security, Medicare, and federal income taxes.
State Taxes: Comply with state income tax and unemployment insurance requirements.
Form Filings: Submit quarterly forms (941, 940) and annual W-2s or 1099s.
Pro Tip: Use payroll software that automatically calculates and files taxes to avoid errors.
6. Monitor Grant and Restricted Fund Payroll
For nonprofits with grant-funded staff, payroll management must align with funder requirements.
Best Practices:
Track grant-funded hours separately from general operating expenses.
Ensure expenses align with grant budgets and allowable costs.
Prepare detailed payroll reports for grant compliance and audits.
Pro Tip: Set reminders for grant reporting deadlines to avoid last-minute stress.
7. Maintain Accurate Payroll Records
Accurate record-keeping is essential for audits, reporting, and compliance.
What to Track:
Pay stubs, tax filings, and employee records.
Documentation for benefits and deductions.
Timesheets or time-tracking logs for hourly staff.
Pro Tip: Retain payroll records for at least seven years, as required by law.
8. Automate Where Possible
Automation saves time and reduces the risk of errors in payroll processing.
How to Automate:
Set up direct deposit for employees.
Use automated tax filings and payment scheduling.
Leverage time-tracking software to integrate hours with payroll systems.
Pro Tip: Many payroll providers offer mobile apps for added convenience.
9. Train Staff on Payroll Processes
Ensure that all staff involved in payroll understand the system and compliance requirements.
Training Topics:
How to submit timesheets or expense reimbursements.
Policies for overtime, vacation, and sick leave.
Procedures for resolving payroll discrepancies.
Pro Tip: Provide a quick-reference guide or FAQ for employees.
10. Regularly Review and Improve Payroll Processes
Payroll management is an ongoing process that requires periodic review.
What to Review:
Compliance with tax and labor laws.
Accuracy of payroll allocations and reporting.
Employee feedback on payroll timeliness and clarity.
Pro Tip: Schedule an annual review of payroll systems to identify and address inefficiencies.
Final Thoughts
Managing payroll for nonprofits requires attention to detail, compliance, and efficiency. By implementing these tips, bookkeepers can ensure that payroll runs smoothly, supports accurate financial reporting, and aligns with the organization’s mission and funding requirements.
For more nonprofit financial management tips, subscribe to my Substack today!
💼 How to Manage Payroll for Nonprofits: Tips for Bookkeepers 💼
Payroll is one of the most important aspects of nonprofit financial management. Here’s how to do it effectively:
✅ Understand Components: Track wages, taxes, benefits, and reimbursements accurately.
✅ Choose the Right System: Use tools like Gusto, QuickBooks, or grant-specific platforms.
✅ Track Worker Status: Differentiate between employees and contractors to stay compliant.
✅ Allocate Costs: Align payroll expenses with programs and grants using time-tracking tools.
✅ Stay Tax-Compliant: Automate filings for federal, state, and local payroll taxes.
✅ Monitor Grant Payroll: Ensure grant-funded staff costs align with budgets and reporting requirements.
✅ Automate Processes: Use direct deposit and integrated systems to save time and reduce errors.
A well-managed payroll system supports compliance, transparency, and staff satisfaction.
Check out my latest Substack article for more insights!
💬 What’s your top tip for managing payroll in a nonprofit? Let’s discuss below!
#NonprofitFinance #PayrollManagement #BookkeepingTips #NonprofitAccounting #FinancialManagement