Dealing with Lapsed Donors: How to Re-Engage and Retain Them
Donor retention is crucial for the sustainability of any nonprofit organization. Yet, even with the best efforts, donors sometimes drift away. Lapsed donors—those who have given in the past but haven't donated recently—represent both a challenge and an opportunity. Re-engaging them can be more cost-effective than acquiring new donors and can revitalize your fundraising efforts. Here's how to reconnect and retain your lapsed donors.
1. Understand Why Donors Lapse
Before you can effectively re-engage lapsed donors, it's important to understand why they stopped giving. Common reasons include:
Lack of Communication: Donors may feel disconnected if they don't hear from your organization regularly.
Perceived Lack of Impact: They might not see how their contributions are making a difference.
Life Changes: Personal circumstances like financial hardship or changes in interests.
Donor Fatigue: Over-solicitation can lead to disengagement.
Action Step: Conduct surveys or personal outreach to gather feedback on why they lapsed.
2. Segment Your Lapsed Donors
Not all lapsed donors are the same. Segmenting allows for tailored communication.
By Recency: How long ago did they last give?
By Frequency: How often did they donate?
By Amount: What was their average gift size?
Action Step: Use your CRM to create donor segments for targeted re-engagement strategies.
3. Personalize Your Outreach
Generic messages won't resonate. Personalization shows you value them individually.
Use Their Name: Address them personally in communications.
Reference Past Contributions: Mention the specific campaigns or programs they supported.
Tailor the Message: Align your appeal with their interests and giving history.
4. Share Impactful Stories
Show them how their past donations have made a difference.
Success Stories: Highlight real-life outcomes of your work.
Updates: Provide progress reports on projects they supported.
Visual Content: Use photos and videos to illustrate impact.
Action Step: Create a compelling narrative that connects their past support to current successes.
5. Offer Exclusive Opportunities
Make them feel special and appreciated.
Invitations to Events: Exclusive events or webinars.
Behind-the-Scenes Access: Insider updates or tours.
Recognition: Acknowledge them in newsletters or on social media (with permission).
6. Make Giving Easy
Reduce barriers to donating.
Simplify the Process: Ensure your donation page is user-friendly.
Multiple Channels: Offer various ways to give (online, mail, phone).
Recurring Donations: Encourage setting up monthly gifts.
7. Re-Establish Trust
If the lapse was due to a negative experience, address it directly.
Acknowledge Issues: Apologize if appropriate.
Show Improvements: Explain changes made since their last engagement.
Invite Dialogue: Encourage them to share any concerns.
8. Stay Connected
Consistency is key to retention.
Regular Updates: Send newsletters and updates without always asking for donations.
Engagement Opportunities: Invite them to volunteer or participate in events.
Express Gratitude: Thank them promptly and sincerely for any renewed support.
Final Thoughts
Re-engaging lapsed donors requires effort, but the rewards are worth it. By understanding their reasons for stepping back and offering personalized, meaningful interactions, you can rebuild these valuable relationships. Remember, reactivated donors can become some of your most loyal supporters.
Want more insights on boosting donor retention and effective fundraising? Subscribe to my Substack for weekly tips and strategies tailored for nonprofit success!
Great advice here! As challenging as it can be to reengage lapsed donors, it's often easier than securing new longtime donors.